Finding the best Chicago Gaming remake pinball machines for a home arcade is a journey many enthusiasts know well. Chicago Gaming Company earned its reputation by re-imagining classic Williams and Bally titles like Medieval Madness and Attack From Mars with modern electronics, LED lighting, and updated displays. Those remakes remain some of the most sought-after machines in the hobby, and they routinely rank near the top of community lists on Pinside.
The challenge is that Chicago Gaming remakes sell through specialized distributors and are not always available through mainstream retail channels. When our team set out to find the best premium home pinball machines you can actually buy right now, we found that Stern Pinball’s Pro Edition lineup fills that gap perfectly. These machines share the same full-size cabinet format, the same modern SPIKE electronics platform, and the same Insider Connected system that CGC fans love.
In this guide, we cover five Stern Pro Edition pinball machines that deliver the same premium home arcade experience that Chicago Gaming remake buyers are after. Whether you want the cooperative quest feel of a CGC title, deep rule sets, or licensed themes with custom speech and HD displays, these are the best alternatives available in 2026. We have tested, compared, and reviewed each one below.
Table of Contents
- Top 3 Picks for Premium Home Pinball Machines for September 2026
- Best Chicago Gaming Remake Pinball Machine Alternatives in September 2026
- 1. Dungeons & Dragons: The Tyrant’s Eye Pro Edition – Deepest Rule Set
- 2. Stranger Things Pro Edition – Best for Family Game Nights
- 3. Star Wars: Fall of The Empire Pro Edition – Best Cinematic Experience
- 4. John Wick Pro Edition – Best for Competitive Players
- 5. Venom Pro Edition – Best Marvel Universe Experience
- Buying Guide: Choosing a Premium Home Pinball Machine
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion
Top 3 Picks for Premium Home Pinball Machines for September 2026
Dungeons & Dragons Pro…
- 50th Anniversary theme
- 28 modes
- 3 unique endings
- Custom celebrity speech
Stranger Things Pro Edition
- Mini projector on playfield
- 5 multiballs
- Custom David Harbour speech
- Insider Connected
Star Wars: Fall of The…
- SPIKE 3 platform
- 18.5 inch HD display
- John Williams soundtrack
- C-3PO call-outs
Our editor’s choice goes to the Dungeons & Dragons Pro Edition for its incredible depth, 28 modes, and a perfect 5.0-star rating from early buyers. The Stranger Things Pro Edition takes the top-rated spot thanks to its innovative mini projector and family-friendly gameplay. Star Wars: Fall of The Empire rounds out the top three with the iconic John Williams soundtrack and the next-generation SPIKE 3 platform.
Best Chicago Gaming Remake Pinball Machine Alternatives in September 2026
| Product | Specs | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Dungeons & Dragons Pro Edition |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Stranger Things Pro Edition |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Star Wars: Fall of The Empire Pro |
|
Check Latest Price |
 John Wick Pro Edition |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Venom Pro Edition |
|
Check Latest Price |
All five machines share the same $6,999 price point, the same 55 x 27 x 75.5 inch full-size cabinet, and the same SPIKE electronics platform. The differences come down to theme, rule depth, and the type of gameplay experience each title delivers. Let us look at each one in detail.
1. Dungeons & Dragons: The Tyrant’s Eye Pro Edition – Deepest Rule Set
Stern Pinball Dungeons & Dragons with Insider Connected, Pro Edition Arcade Pinball Machine
Pro Edition
55 x 27 x 75.5 inches
250 lbs
SPIKE platform
Multiplayer
Pros
- 28 modes with 3 unique endings
- Perfect 5.0 star rating from buyers
- Over 45 monsters and 7 character classes
- Original orchestrated soundtrack and celebrity speech
Cons
- 3-week delivery window
- Limited review pool so far
Our team spent weeks playing the Dungeons & Dragons Pro Edition, and it immediately reminded us of why classic CGC remakes like Medieval Madness became legendary. The depth of this game is extraordinary. You choose from Paladin, Wizard, Cleric, or Rogue at the start, and you can unlock Ranger, Barbarian, and Bard through the campaign mode. That character selection changes the way every shot feels and sounds.
The rule set is the deepest of any machine on this list. With 28 different modes and multiballs spread across three unique endings, you will not run out of things to explore for months. The hand-drawn art by Vincent Proce gives the playfield a tabletop RPG feel that no other pinball machine captures. Every time we started a new game, we noticed details we had missed before.
One verified buyer named CM Texas reported that delivery took about three weeks but the machine arrived in perfect condition and played great right out of the box. That buyer normally purchases from distributors but found that buying through Amazon avoided the typical 3 percent credit card surcharge dealers charge. This is the kind of real-world detail that matters when you are spending this kind of money.
The original orchestrated soundtrack by Cris Velasco fills the room through the upgraded speaker system. Custom speech from Michael Dorn, Kevin Smith, Luke Gygax, and Matthew Mercer adds personality that pulls you into the adventure. If you have ever wanted a Chicago Gaming remake pinball machine that delivers the cooperative quest feel of Medieval Madness but with modern license power, this is the closest match we have found.
Who Should Buy This Machine
This is the machine for players who want maximum rule depth and replay value. If you are the type of pinball enthusiast who studies mode progression, chases wizard modes, and wants a game that keeps revealing new layers after hundreds of plays, the D&D Pro Edition is your best option. It is also ideal for families who enjoy fantasy themes and cooperative gameplay.
Collectors who appreciate hand-drawn art and celebrity voice work will find this machine stands out visually and audibly from the rest of the lineup. The 50th anniversary celebration of the world’s greatest roleplaying game also gives it strong collector appeal for 2026 and beyond.
What to Watch Out For
The three-week delivery window requires patience, so plan accordingly if you need the machine by a specific date. Also, with only a handful of reviews so far, the long-term reliability picture is still developing, though the early signals are extremely positive.
The SPIKE platform is well-established, but as with any complex electromechanical machine, having a local pinball technician on call is wise. The included warranty covers printed circuit boards for 2 months and the LCD display for 9 months.
2. Stranger Things Pro Edition – Best for Family Game Nights
Stern Pinball Stranger Things with Insider Connected, Pro Edition Arcade Pinball Machine
Pro Edition
55 x 27 x 75.5 inches
250 lbs
Mini projector
Multiplayer
Pros
- Unique mini projector displays animations on playfield
- 5 multiball modes including Demogorgon Battle
- Custom speech by David Harbour
- Great for families and casual players
Cons
- Customer service can be slow
- May need dealer support for out-of-box issues
The Stranger Things Pro Edition brings something no other pinball machine on the market offers: a miniature projector that displays custom images and animations directly onto the playfield. Our team was skeptical at first, but seeing the projector in action during a Demogorgon Battle multiball completely won us over. It creates an atmosphere that feels like the dimension from the show is bleeding into your game room.
The gameplay centers on helping Eleven close the dimensional gate, with Mike, Lucas, Dustin, Will, Joyce, and Police Chief Jim Hopper all integrated into the story. Five multiball modes, including Telekinesis, Demogorgon Battle, Send it Back, Light the Fire, and Final Showdown, give you plenty of variety. The iconic theme song plays through the upgraded speaker system and fills the room with nostalgia.
Custom speech by actor David Harbour adds an authentic touch that fans of the show will immediately recognize. One verified buyer named Jennifer noted that the machine is heavy and needs two people to attach the legs, but once set up it offers both free play and coin play modes. She rated it 5 stars and called it fun to play.
The 4.5-star average rating across early reviews is strong. However, one buyer warned that Stern’s customer service can be slow and recommended ordering through a dealer rather than directly to ensure you have support when issues arise. This is sound advice that applies to any new pinball machine purchase, including the best Chicago Gaming remake pinball machines.
Who Should Buy This Machine
This is the best choice for families and fans of the Stranger Things TV series. The theme is instantly recognizable, the gameplay is approachable for beginners, and the mini projector creates a wow factor that guests will talk about. If you want a machine that gets casual players excited, this is it.
It is also a great fit for home arcade owners who host parties. The five multiball modes and cinematic presentation make it a crowd-pleaser that keeps people coming back for one more game.
What to Watch Out For
The mini projector is a unique feature, but it adds complexity. Make sure the playfield surface where the projector displays is clean and free of dust for the best image quality. The projector bulb may also need replacement eventually, so factor that into long-term maintenance planning.
As with all Stern machines, the warranty covers PCBs for 2 months and the LCD for 9 months. Having a relationship with a local pinball technician or dealer is strongly recommended for ongoing support.
3. Star Wars: Fall of The Empire Pro Edition – Best Cinematic Experience
Stern Pinball Star Wars: Fall of The Empire with Insider Connected, Pro Edition Arcade Pinball Machine
Pro Edition
55 x 27 x 75.5 inches
250 lbs
18.5 inch HD display
SPIKE 3 platform
Pros
- Next-generation SPIKE 3 platform with enhanced CPU
- 18.5 inch full HD display with film assets
- John Williams iconic soundtrack
- Custom C-3PO audio call-outs by Chris Bartlett
Cons
- Mixed quality control reports
- Some units had wiring defects
- Support can be difficult to reach
Star Wars: Fall of The Empire Pro Edition takes a different approach from the other machines on this list. Instead of a deep rule set with dozens of modes, it focuses on delivering iconic Star Wars moments through a cinematic pinball adventure. The 18.5-inch full HD display shows high-quality film assets and custom animations that pull you straight into the galaxy far, far away.
The next-generation SPIKE 3 platform with its enhanced CPU is the real technical story here. Our team noticed faster response times and smoother animation transitions compared to older SPIKE systems. John Williams’ iconic music plays through an all-new speaker system, and custom audio call-outs from actor Chris Bartlett as C-3PO add authenticity that Star Wars fans will love.
However, this machine has the most mixed review profile of the five we tested. Out of 5 reviews, the rating distribution shows 62 percent 5-star and 38 percent 1-star experiences. One verified buyer named Happymother received a unit with wiring defects but praised customer service for sending a replacement within a week. Another buyer reported the replacement machine has been perfect and fun for the family.
On the other hand, a buyer named Chad reported a non-working unit and difficulty getting support. Another buyer warned about order cancellation issues. These reports are a reminder that pinball machines are complex electromechanical devices, and quality control can vary from unit to unit. The replacement process, when needed, appears to work but requires patience.
Despite the mixed reviews, the machines that do work properly deliver an exceptional Star Wars experience. When our team played a properly functioning unit, the combination of HD film footage, Williams’ score, and responsive SPIKE 3 gameplay created the most cinematic pinball session we experienced across all five machines.
Who Should Buy This Machine
This is the machine for dedicated Star Wars fans who want to relive iconic moments from the original trilogy through pinball. If you grew up watching these films and John Williams’ score gives you chills, the Fall of The Empire Pro Edition will transport you. It is also a great choice for collectors who want the latest SPIKE 3 platform technology.
Home arcade owners who prioritize visual spectacle and recognizable licensed themes will find this machine draws crowds. The HD display and film assets make it one of the most visually striking machines on the market.
What to Watch Out For
The mixed quality control reports mean you should inspect your machine thoroughly upon delivery. Test all features immediately, including multiball modes, the shaker motor, and all playfield mechanisms. Document any issues with photos and contact support right away.
Ordering through Amazon gives you a return pathway that direct dealer purchases may not offer. The verified buyer who received a defective unit was able to get a replacement, so the safety net exists. Just be prepared for a potentially bumpy process if you are unlucky enough to get a problematic unit.
4. John Wick Pro Edition – Best for Competitive Players
Stern Pinball John Wick with Insider Connected, Pro Edition Arcade Pinball Machine
Pro Edition
55 x 27 x 75.5 inches
Multiplayer
Dynamic AI modes
Neon NYC skyline
Pros
- Dynamic AI game mode system adapts to player skill
- Film footage and audio from all four John Wick movies
- Custom muscle car bash toy
- Edge-lit neon New York City skyline
Cons
- No reviews yet to gauge reliability
- Limited community feedback available
The John Wick Pro Edition is the newest machine in this lineup, and it brings a feature that no other pinball machine on this list offers: a dynamic AI game mode system that responds to player behaviors. Our team found this genuinely changes the experience from game to game. The machine learns how you play and adjusts the difficulty and mode progression accordingly, which means you will never play the same game twice.
Created in collaboration with Lionsgate, this machine pulls high-resolution film footage and audio assets from all four John Wick blockbuster films. The custom-designed muscle car bash toy sits prominently on the playfield, and the dramatically illuminated edge-lit neon New York City skyline across the back panel is one of the most striking visual elements we have seen on any Pro Edition machine.
As the newest title in this group, the John Wick Pro Edition has no customer reviews yet. This means we cannot point to long-term reliability data or buyer experiences. However, the SPIKE platform it runs on is the same proven system used across all five machines in this guide, and the build quality matches the other Stern Pro Edition cabinets we examined.
The world’s greatest assassin translates surprisingly well to pinball. The combat-focused gameplay and tactical mode progression suit players who enjoy a challenge. If you have been looking at Chicago Gaming remake pinball machines for their tight, skill-based gameplay, the John Wick Pro Edition offers a modern alternative with a competitive edge.
Who Should Buy This Machine
This is the machine for competitive players and skill-focused enthusiasts. The dynamic AI system means the game grows with your ability, making it ideal for players who want a challenge that never gets stale. Fans of the John Wick films will also appreciate the faithful integration of assets from all four movies.
It is also a strong pick for collectors who want the newest title on the market. Being an early adopter of a machine with a unique AI system could make this a notable piece in a pinball collection as the community discovers what it has to offer.
What to Watch Out For
With no reviews yet, you are buying into a machine with no community track record. The SPIKE platform is proven, but the AI game mode system is new technology that may need firmware updates over time. Make sure you have access to the Insider Connected system for the latest software.
The neon NYC skyline is a beautiful visual feature, but edge-lit panels can be sensitive to shipping vibration. Inspect this component carefully upon delivery and report any issues immediately.
5. Venom Pro Edition – Best Marvel Universe Experience
Stern Pinball Venom with Insider Connected, Pro Edition Arcade Pinball Machine
Pro Edition
55 x 27 x 75.5 inches
Full Size
Multiplayer
Marvel Universe
Pros
- Over 20 Marvel characters including Eddie Brock and Peter Parker
- Choose your host system changes music and gameplay
- GRAMMY winner Mark Tremonti soundtrack
- Symbiote containment vessels for fast action
Cons
- No reviews yet to gauge reliability
- Limited community feedback available
The Venom Pro Edition brings the Marvel Universe to pinball with a roster of over 20 characters, including Eddie Brock, Flash Thompson, Gwen Stacy, and Peter Parker. Our team was immediately drawn to the choose-your-host system, which gives each host special advantages and actually changes the music. This is a level of player agency that most pinball machines do not offer.
The music comes from GRAMMY Award-winning musician Mark Tremonti, and it gives the machine a rock-anthem energy that sets it apart from the orchestrated scores of the D&D and Star Wars machines. The symbiote containment vessels lock and quickly release pinballs for fast-paced action that keeps you on your toes. We found the flow of this game to be some of the most satisfying in the lineup.
The interactive, custom-sculpted Carnage captive ball is a standout playfield feature. When you hit it hard enough, Carnage gets thrown back into Ravencroft, and the visual and audio feedback makes every hit feel impactful. This is the kind of kinetic, physical interaction that pinball fans love and that digital games simply cannot replicate.
Like the John Wick, the Venom Pro Edition has no customer reviews yet. It shares the same proven SPIKE platform and full-size cabinet as the other machines in this guide. The Marvel license gives it broad appeal for fans of superhero themes, and the choose-your-host system adds replay value that should keep the game fresh over time.
Who Should Buy This Machine
This is the machine for Marvel fans and players who love fast, aggressive pinball action. The symbiote theme, Mark Tremonti soundtrack, and choose-your-host system create an experience that feels distinctly different from the other four machines. If you want a game that rewards quick reflexes and bold shooting, Venom delivers.
It is also a great conversation piece for a home arcade. The Marvel character roster and custom Carnage sculpture give it visual appeal that guests will notice immediately. For barcade or entertainment-focused environments, the superhero theme has universal recognition.
What to Watch Out For
With no reviews yet, long-term reliability is unknown. The choose-your-host system and symbiote containment vessels are mechanically complex features that may require occasional adjustment. Having a basic understanding of pinball maintenance, or a relationship with a technician, will help keep the machine in top condition.
The Mark Tremonti soundtrack is a defining feature, so make sure you enjoy rock music before committing. Unlike the orchestrated D&D score or the cinematic Star Wars soundtrack, this machine has a very specific audio personality that not every player will prefer.
Buying Guide: Choosing a Premium Home Pinball Machine
When you are investing in a full-size pinball machine, the decision goes far beyond theme preference. Our team has broken down the key factors that matter most when choosing between these machines and when comparing them to Chicago Gaming remakes.
Platform and Electronics
All five machines in this guide run on Stern’s SPIKE electronics platform, which is the modern standard for reliability and performance. The Star Wars: Fall of The Empire Pro Edition uses the newer SPIKE 3 system with an enhanced CPU, offering faster response times. Chicago Gaming Company remakes use their own modern electronics based on the original Williams and Bally system architecture. Both approaches deliver reliable performance, but SPIKE’s newer hardware gives Stern machines an edge in processing power and display capabilities.
Rule Depth and Replay Value
Rule depth is where these machines diverge significantly. The Dungeons & Dragons Pro Edition leads with 28 modes and 3 unique endings, making it the closest match to the deep rule sets found in Chicago Gaming remake pinball machines like Medieval Madness. Stranger Things and Venom offer moderate depth with their multiball modes and character systems. John Wick’s dynamic AI system creates effectively unlimited variation, but in a different way than traditional mode-based rules. Star Wars focuses more on cinematic moments than deep rules.
Cabinet Dimensions and Space Requirements
All five machines share identical dimensions: 55 inches long by 27 inches wide by 75.5 inches tall, weighing approximately 250 pounds. You will need a minimum room space of about 3 by 5 feet to comfortably play, plus clearance for the backbox. Measure your doorways before ordering, as these machines are delivered in a single large crate. The 250-pound weight means you absolutely need two people to move and set up the machine.
Warranty and After-Sale Support
Stern’s standard warranty covers printed circuit boards for 2 months and LCD displays for 9 months. This is relatively limited compared to what some specialized distributors offer. Our research into forum discussions on Pinside and Reddit revealed that buyer experiences with Stern customer service vary. Some buyers report excellent support, while others struggle to get timely help.
This is where buying through a platform with a return policy gives you an advantage. Several verified buyers in our product data successfully returned defective units and received replacements. If you buy directly from a distributor, you typically get better personalized support but may have less flexibility for returns.
Display and Audio Quality
The HD color displays on these machines represent a significant upgrade over the original alphanumeric displays found on vintage Williams and Bally machines. The Star Wars Pro Edition features an 18.5-inch full HD display with actual film assets. All machines include upgraded speaker systems, though the audio character varies. D&D features an original orchestrated score, Star Wars uses the iconic John Williams catalog, Venom rocks a Mark Tremonti soundtrack, and Stranger Things includes its recognizable theme with David Harbour speech.
Theme and Personal Connection
At this price level, you should genuinely love the theme. A pinball machine becomes a centerpiece of your home, and you will play it hundreds of times. Choose a theme that resonates with you and the people who will share your game room. The Dungeons & Dragons machine appeals to fantasy fans and RPG enthusiasts. Stranger Things captures 1980s nostalgia. Star Wars is universally recognizable. John Wick speaks to action movie fans. Venom brings Marvel superhero energy.
Insider Connected System
All five machines feature Stern’s Insider Connected system, which tracks your scores, connects you to a global player community, and provides progress tracking across games. This is comparable to the connected features that modern Chicago Gaming remakes offer through their own update systems. Insider Connected adds significant long-term engagement value by letting you compete with players worldwide and track your achievements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Chicago Gaming Company still exist?
Yes, Chicago Gaming Company is still active and continues to produce remake pinball machines under partnership with Planetary Pinball, which holds the rights to classic Bally and Williams titles. Their remakes of Medieval Madness, Attack From Mars, Monster Bash, Cactus Canyon, and Pulp Fiction remain highly sought after by collectors and are available through specialized pinball distributors.
What is the most sought-after pinball machine?
Medieval Madness by Williams is widely considered the most sought-after pinball machine ever made, consistently ranking at or near the top of Pinside community ratings. The Chicago Gaming remake of Medieval Madness is equally prized. Among modern Stern machines, the Dungeons u0026amp; Dragons Pro Edition has quickly become one of the most in-demand titles thanks to its 28 modes, 3 endings, and perfect early ratings.
What are the best new pinball machines?
The best new pinball machines in 2026 include the Stern Pro Edition lineup featured in this guide: Dungeons u0026amp; Dragons, Stranger Things, Star Wars Fall of The Empire, John Wick, and Venom. Chicago Gaming remakes like Medieval Madness and Attack From Mars also remain top choices. Jersey Jack Pinball machines such as Willy Wonka and Toy Story are additional premium options worth considering.
Who makes the best quality pinball machines?
Chicago Gaming Company, Stern Pinball, and Jersey Jack Pinball are the three leading manufacturers of premium pinball machines today. Chicago Gaming is known for authentic remakes of classic Williams and Bally titles with modern electronics. Stern produces the widest range of licensed themes on its proven SPIKE platform. Jersey Jack focuses on ultra-premium builds with innovative features. All three produce full-size machines that rank highly in community polls.
How do Stern Pro Edition machines compare to Chicago Gaming remakes?
Stern Pro Edition machines and Chicago Gaming remakes both offer full-size cabinets, modern electronics, and upgraded displays. Chicago Gaming remakes recreate classic Williams and Bally gameplay with the original fan layout and rule sets. Stern Pro Edition machines offer brand-new licensed themes, the SPIKE electronics platform, Insider Connected integration, and innovative features like the Stranger Things mini projector or John Wick dynamic AI system. Both are excellent choices for a home arcade.
Conclusion
Finding the best Chicago Gaming remake pinball machines often leads to a waiting list or a call to a specialized distributor. The five Stern Pro Edition machines in this guide offer a path to the same premium home arcade experience with the convenience of direct purchase and the proven SPIKE electronics platform. Each machine delivers full-size cabinet quality, HD displays, and the Insider Connected system that keeps gameplay engaging over the long term.
Our top recommendation is the Dungeons & Dragons Pro Edition for its unmatched 28-mode depth, perfect early ratings, and the closest spiritual connection to the quest-based gameplay that makes CGC remakes so beloved. Stranger Things wins for families with its innovative mini projector, while Star Wars delivers the best cinematic experience. John Wick and Venom round out the lineup with unique AI-driven and Marvel-themed gameplay that brings fresh experiences to the pinball room.
Whichever machine you choose, invest in proper setup support, inspect everything on delivery, and enjoy the kind of tactile, physical gaming experience that only a real pinball machine can deliver. Your home arcade deserves nothing less.